Case Name : DS Nakara and Others vs Union of India

Case Reference: (1983) 2 SCR 165 : (1983) 1 SCC 305

Neutral Citation: 1982 INSC 103

Case Number: WP 5939/1980

Court: Supreme Court

Bench: 05

Coram: Chief Justice YV Chandrachud, VD Tulzapurkar, DA Desai (Author), O Chinnappa Reddy, Baharul Islam

Date: 17.12.1982

Over-classification impermissible; date of retirement is a not a valid form for classification, otherwise people who retire at the end of every month would form a separate class. Doctrine of severability

Burden to justify legislative or ad

Pension is a payment for past service rendered. Pension is not a bounty. Pension is not a matter of grace. pension defined; meaning of pension (Paras 27, 31)

Emphasis on precedent is a roadblock towards socio-economic justice (Para 41)

– Refer also:

See also: Constitution - Article 13

Constitution - Article 14

Constitution - Article 16

Constitution - Article 32

Constitution - Article 141

PDF: DS Nakara vs UoI, (1983) 2 SCR 165.pdf

Web Link: URL of judgment